The Therapeutics Initiative is at arms length from government and other vested interest groups. Our function is unbiased review and dissemination of therapeutic evidence. Assessments apply to most patients; exceptional patients require exceptional approaches. We are committed to evaluate the effectiveness of our educational activities using the Pharmacare database without identifying individual physicians, pharmacies or patients.


Therapeutics Letter, issue 12, January/February 1996

Changing Concepts in the Management of Asthma


Asthma and other conditions associated with bronchospasm are extremely prevalent and evidence suggests that the prevalence and severity is increasing. A measure of the magnitude of the problem in British Columbia is the fact that the b2-agonist salbutamol is the second most frequently prescribed drug, after acetaminophen/codeine combinations. Most b2-agonists are prescribed to relieve episodic bronchospasm in ambulatory patients with asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. This Letter is focused on the optimal management of asthma in the primary care setting.

What are the goals of therapy?

What are the non-pharmacological therapies?

What is the role of the following drugs in the management of asthma?

Salbutamol (Ventolin) and Other Short-acting b2-Agonists.

b2-agonists cause bronchodilation by smooth muscle relaxation, and when administered by the inhaled route, are effective and safe for the management of acute asthma exacerbations, in preventing exercise-induced asthma, and for control of intermittent asthma symptoms. They are not recommended for regular daily therapy, because of evidence that daily use of inhaled b2-agonists may lead to a deterioration in asthma control in many patients. One of the better trials (2), compared inhaled fenoterol, 0.2 mg QID for 24 weeks with a inhaled placebo for 24 weeks in a double-blind, randomized crossover study (n=64, 50 taking inhaled corticosteroids). Patients were allowed to use a supplementary b2-agonist as necessary for symptoms. The total average daily amount of b2-agonist was 2.9 and 10.0 puffs in the placebo and fenoterol groups respectively. Eight out of nine measures of asthma control were worse while the patients were receiving regular fenoterol as compared to placebo.

Because of this study and other corroborative evidence, the recent Canadian Asthma Consensus conference recommends that when short-acting inhaled b2-agonists are required more frequently than three times weekly (not including their use to prevent exercise-induced symptoms) maintenance therapy with anti-inflammatory drugs is indicated (1). Oral liquid and tablet formulations of b2-agonists are not recommended.

Short acting inhaled b2-agonists

Generic Name Strength Trade Name Dose Cost / Puff*
Salbutamol 0.1 mg generic, MDI 1-2 puffs prn $0.03
Salbutamol 0.2 mg Ventodisk 1-2 puffs prn $0.18
Salbutamol 0.2 mg Rotacaps 1-2 puffs prn $0.18
Terbutaline 0.5 mg Bricanyl, Turb 1-2 puffs prn $0.08
Orciprenaline 0.65 mg Alupent, MDI 1-2 puffs prn $0.05
Fenoterol 0.1 mg Berotec, MDI 1-2 puffs prn $0.05
Procaterol 0.01 mg Pro-air, MDI 1-2 puffs prn $0.09

* Based on average cost to Pharmacare || MDI = metered dose inhaler || Turb = turbuhaler

Inhaled, oral, and parenteral corticosteroids.

Corticosteroids are anti-inflammatory drugs which reduce two major components of asthma, i.e. the inflammatory changes in the airway and airway hyper-responsiveness. In acute severe asthma, systemic corticosteroids are safe and effective; oral prednisone (50 mg) is just as effective as low or high dose parenteral corticosteroids (3). In patients with daily symptoms, regular inhaled steroids are more effective than regular inhaled b2-agonists (4). Administration once or twice daily improves compliance and is effective for most patients; the dose and frequency of administration can be individualized to optimize symptom control and spirometry.

You may have to start with high dose inhaled corticosteroids to control symptoms, but always use the lowest dose of inhaled corticosteroids required to maintain good asthma control; in stable patients repeated trials of dose reduction should be attempted, including stopping the inhaler if possible. Unfortunately, the inhaled corticosteroids do not "cure" asthma; cessation of regular use often results in return to the previous status within weeks to months.

Side effects are infrequent; the risk of oropharyngeal candidiasis can be reduced by post-inhalation gargling with water, plus the use of a spacer with metered dose inhalers (MDI) to reduce the amount of steroid deposited in the oropharynx. Inhaled corticosteroids have minimal systemic effects at doses of at least 0.4 mg per day for children and 0.8 mg per day for adults (5). Higher doses are usually well tolerated.

Low dose inhaled corticosteroids

Generic Name Strength Trade Name Dose* Daily Cost**
Beclomethasone 0.050 mg generic, MDI 4 puffs BID $0.34
Beclomethasone 0.100 mg Beclodisk 4 puffs BID $1.85
Beclomethasone 0.200 mg Beclodisk 2 puffs BID $1.24
Beclomethasone 0.100 mg Rotacaps 4 puffs BID $0.92
Beclomethasone 0.200 mg Rotacaps 2 puffs BID $1.32
Budesonide 0.100 mg Pulmicort, Turb 2 puffs BID $0.64
Flunisolide 0.250 mg Bronalide, MDI 2 puffs BID $0.68
Fluticasone 0.025 mg Flovent, MDI *** 4 puffs BID $0.78
Fluticasone 0.050 mg Flovent, MDI *** 2 puffs BID $0.76
Triamcinolone 0.200 mg Azmacort, MDI 4 puffs BID $0.64

* Dose to achieve the approximate bio-equivalent of 0.4 mg beclomethasone || **Based on average cost to Pharmacare || *** Not a Pharmacare when this was published || MDI = metered dose inhaler || Turb = turbuhaler

High dose inhaled corticosteroids

Generic Name Strength Trade Name Dose* Daily Cost**
Beclomethasone 0.250 mg Becloforte, MDI 2 puffs BID $1.48
Budesonide 0.200 mg Pulmicort, Turb 2 puffs BID $1.24
Budesonide 0.400 mg Pulmicort, Turb 1 puff BID $1.12
Fluticasone 0.125 mg Flovent, MDI *** 2 puffs BID $1.20
Fluticasone 0.250 mg Flovent, MDI *** 1 puff BID $1.20

* Dose to achieve the approximate bio-equivalent of 0.4 mg beclomethasone || **Based on average cost to Pharmacare || *** Not a Pharmacare when this was published || MDI = metered dose inhaler || Turb = turbuhaler

Cromoglycate and nedocromil inhalers and oral ketotifen.

These non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs act by preventing the release of inflammatory mediators and are used prophylactically. They are very safe and have a role in some patients, particularly children, when they have been proven effective in a therapeutic trial. In moderate to severe asthma, however, they are not generally as effective as inhaled corticosteroids. They have no role in managing acute exacerbations of asthma.

Other anti-inflammatory drugs

Generic Name Strength Trade Name Dose Daily Cost*
Cromoglycate 1 mg Intal, MDI 2 puffs QID $1.92
Nedocromil 2 mg Tilade, MDI 2 puffs QID $2.08
Ketotifen 1 mg tab/syrup Zaditen ½ to 1 tab. BID $1.78

* Based on average cost to Pharmacare || MDI = metered dose inhaler

Long-acting b2-agonists.

Because of concerns about chronic adverse consequences of b2-agonists (6), this class of drugs should be restricted to patients who remain symptomatic despite inhaled beclomethasone 1.0 mg or equivalent daily. Two randomized-controlled trials have shown superior control with the addition of salmeterol compared to doubling the dose of inhaled corticosteroids. Patients taking this medication should be carefully monitored and warned not to discontinue their maintenance anti-inflammatory therapy. It is usually prescribed as a twice daily regimen. Individual n-of-1 studies may allow modification of its use to once daily dosing especially at night for nocturnal symptoms; however, there are no controlled trials using once daily dosing. Patients should be cautioned not to use this class of drug in acute asthma.

Long acting inhaled b2-agonists

Generic Name Strength Trade Name Dose Daily Cost
Salmeterol 0.025 mg Serevent, MDI 2 puffs BID $1.90
Salmeterol 0.05 mg Diskhaler 1 puff BID $2.04

* Based on wholesale cost || MDI = metered dose inhaler

Oral theophylline.

Theophylline is a weak bronchodilator which may also have some anti-inflammatory activities. A number of slow release preparations are available. Because of significant dose related toxicity, serum level monitoring is recommended. Theophylline should be reserved for patients who remain symptomatic despite optimization of inhaled corticosteroids.

Inhaled ipratropium bromide.

The evidence is equivocal as to the role of this inhaled anticholinergic bronchdilator in the management of acute or chronic asthma. It acts more slowly than b2-agonists and at best is an adjunctive agent in particular patients where it has been proven to be helpful by a therapeutic trial.

What is the role of the different inhaler devices and peak expiratory flow (PEF) meters?

Repeated assessment of the adequacy of patient aerosol technique in the doctor's office is essential. The device that best fits the needs of the patient should be selected. Early reassessment of asthma control is essential, whenever a change in device is made (1). Home PEF measurements are helpful in managing more complicated patients; they provide a valuable objective measure of effect when adjustments in medication are attempted.

Conclusion:

Regular inhaled corticosteroids are the main therapy in asthmatic patients with frequent symptoms or exacerbations. Use inhaled b2-agonists for intermittent relief or breakthrough symptoms only. For all treatments always have an objective goal and measure of efficacy and titrate the dose to identify the lowest dose that will achieve that goal.


REFERENCES

  1. Canadian Asthma Consensus Conference Can Respir J 1996 (in press)
  2. Sears MR, Taylor DR, Print CG, et al. Regular inhaled beta-agonist treatment in bronchial asthma. Lancet 1990; 336: 1391-96, Thorax 1993; 48:134-138.
  3. Marquette CH, Stach B, Cardott E, et al. High-dose and low-dose systemic corticosteroids are equally efficient in acute severe asthma. Eur Respir J 1995; 8:22-27.
  4. Haahtela T, Järvinen M, Kava T, et al. Comparison of a b2-agonist, terbutaline, with an inhaled corticosteroid budesonide, in newly detected asthma. N Engl J Med 1991; 325:388-92.
  5. Barnes PJ. Inhaled glucocorticoids for asthma. N Engl J Med 1995; 332(13):868-75.
  6. Grove A, Lipworth BJ. Bronchodilator subsensitivity to salbutamol after twice daily salmeterol in asthmatic patients. Lancet 1995; 346:201-06.

Please send feedback!

Back to Therapeutics Letter.

Back to the Therapeutics Initiative Home Page.

©Therapeutics Initiative. Last updated: March 27, 1996.