13 Jul 2022  Physical activity is medicine: Prescribe it
Inactivity is a modifiable risk factor for chronic disease and, according to the World Health Organization, the fourth leading risk factor for death worldwide.1,2 Exercise has demonstrated benefits for dozens of chronic diseases, yet 80% of Canadians do not meet physical activity guidelines.3
Clinicians may feel they lack time or ability to address the common barriers to prescribing exercise,1 and exercise prescriptions (ExRx) are not taught in most medical curricula.4 This Letter presents systematic review evidence about exercise prescriptions in primary care, and suggests some practical ways to employ ExRx in your practice.
Defining exercise that improves health
Recent Canadian movement guidelines recommend at least 2 sessions of resistance training per week, plus 150 minutes of moderate to vigorous physical activity.5 Moderate-intensity aerobic activity (e.g. fast walking, swimming, snow shoeing) makes breathing harder than normal: one can talk, but not sing. Vigorous activity increases heart rate and makes it difficult to say more than a few words without needing to catch one’s breath. This can be achieved in fast team sports (e.g. soccer, basketball, hockey), fast cycling, jogging or running, swimming laps, or uphill climbing (e.g. stair climbing, hiking, cross-country skiing).
Evidence from systematic reviews
We searched for systematic reviews (SRs) of controlled trials of interventions to prescribe exercise in primary care settings for adults with or without chronic disease. Experimental interventions studied in trials include writing an exercise prescription (ExRx) and comparable simple interventions such as advice or counselling, or prescribing a free pass to a recreation program (versus no ExRx or standard primary care). Outcomes assessed were mostly physical activity levels. There is much less experimental evidence from primary care about improvements in clinically important outcomes or other outcomes important to patients.
We identified 7 relevant systematic reviews.6-12 Most of the underlying clinical trials ranged from 2 to 12 months, but 2 SRs included studies with over 12 months of follow-up. Five SRs included meta-analyses; 4 of 5 found a positive effect of an ExRx (or equivalent) on physical activity levels. The remaining 2 of 7 SRs found mixed results, as they reviewed studies of various different interventions.
These systematic reviews generally found that exercise counselling is modestly effective at increasing physical activity. For example, a SR of 15 trials involving 8,745 people found a number needed to treat (NNT) of 12 (95% CI 7-33) for 1 sedentary adult to achieve internationally recommended physical activity at 12 months.10 The same SR identified 3 trials in which exercise referrals (e.g. to a community centre or walking program) were no more effective than recommendations directly from a primary care doctor or nurse. Neither patient choice of the type of exercise (self-directed) nor physician-prescribed exercise has been shown preferable to increase activity. There is no evidence that recommending any specific type of exercise leads to better adherence.7
Because the underlying clinical trials studied so many different interventions (e.g. writing an ExRx in the clinic, a reminder phone call from a nurse, or handing out information in a counselling session) head-to-head comparisons of such interventions are not possible. Available evidence is also subject to biases arising from incomplete blinding of investigators, subjective outcome reporting (e.g. self-reported physical activity levels), and loss of participants to follow-up.
Can exercise prescriptions cause harm?
Two key issues to consider are exercise-induced cardiovascular events and musculoskeletal injury from falls. The risk of exercise-triggered CV events may be highest in sedentary people, but this can be mitigated by clinically appropriate screening or investigations before initiating an exercise program.13 People at low CV or metabolic risk gain little from screening before recommending exercise.
Most trials of exercise interventions did not report musculoskeletal injuries and falls due to exercise. When reported, incidence was similar in the intervention and control groups. A consistent message from research studies is that the very low risks of an exercise program should be weighed against the clinically important disadvantages of remaining sedentary.14
Some exercise is better than none
To achieve substantial health benefits, including prevention of chronic diseases or premature death, at least 150 minutes per week of moderate to vigorous physical activity is recommended.2,14 However, people who do little or no exercise can improve their health by small changes in behaviour, such as substituting light-intensity activity for sitting time.13 U.S. investigators concluded: “there is no threshold that must be exceeded before benefits begin to accrue.”14
The United States National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) measured physical activity from 2003 to 2006 in 4,840 adults aged > 40 (mean age 57, 53% women) who wore an accelerometer for 7 days. During mean follow-up of 10 years, the investigators found that “increasing moderate to vigorous physical activity by 10, 20, or 30 minutes per day was associated with a 6.9%, 13.0%, and 16.9% decrease in the number of deaths per year, respectively.”15
Do patients want us to recommend exercise?
Clinicians may have different responses to this question, but asking our patients might yield surprising or gratifying answers.
Prescribing physical activity in primary care
Prescribers can offer simple encouragement or more comprehensive interventions incorporating specific counselling and an individualized ExRx. Common barriers to activity include lack of motivation, insufficient time, pain, or loneliness. Helping people to change entrenched behaviours is not easy. Behavioural expert BJ Fogg’s simple model focuses on 3 factors:16
- Start simple
- Find a time when physical activity fits
- Remind yourself to do it
Then celebrate success and repeat.
5A framework is more comprehensive
- Ask: Determine the patient’s current activity level: “What activities do you like, and how much are you doing them?” This helps evaluate motivation, and identify activities that are safe and enjoyable for the patient. Remember: “If it’s not fun, it’s not sustainable.”
- Advise: Physical activity according to Canadian guidelines.5
- Agree: Formulate individualized goals in discussion and collaboration with the patient. Record the agreed goals as an ExRx.
- Assist: Provide resources (online, handouts, etc.) or referrals (if needed) to other health care or exercise professionals. For some patient resources to encourage activity see below.
- Arrange: Schedule activity follow-ups.
- Physical inactivity is a major but modifiable risk factor for chronic disease.
- Exercise is medicine. Clinicians should routinely recommend and monitor physical activity options with their patients.
- Even small increases in activity can improve health.
- In primary care, recommending exercise is good. Writing an exercise prescription to increase physical activity is better.
What is an exercise (activity) prescription?
An ExRx resembles a drug Rx, but substitutes:
- Type of activity: e.g. uphill walking, rowing, skating
- Intensity of activity: e.g. gentle walking, moderate swimming, vigorous cycling
- Dose: how much per session, e.g. minutes, steps, distance
- Frequency: how often, e.g. daily, twice a day
- Duration, repeats & review: when?
Write the indication and follow-up to reinforce the message, e.g. “Walk briskly and every day for at least 30 minutes to reduce blood pressure and lower blood sugar. Let’s reassess your progress in 4 weeks.”
(recommendations of Josh Levin MD, CCFP of Victoria, B.C.)
- Dr Mike Evans: 23 ½ hours (video)
- J Thornton et al. Physical Activity Prescription – A Position Statement by the Canadian Academy of Sport and Exercise Medicine (CASEM) July 2016
- Prescribing physical activity podcast with Dr Jane Thornton: Part 1 (episode 388) and Part 2 (episode 389). BJSM podcast from BMJ talk medicine
- The Knowledge Project with Shane Parrish podcast, Episode #86. BJ Fogg: Create Lasting Change
- Canadian Academy of Sport and Exercise Medicine (CASEM): Medicine through movement resources
- Canadian Family Physician (CFP): Patient Education Materials on Physical Activity
- British Association of Sport & Exercise Medicine (BASEM): Motivate2Move – a guide for the health professional on the benefits of physical activity
- Professional Associations for Physical Activity (Sweden): Physical Activity in the Prevention and Treatment of Disease
- WHO Global Action Plan on Physical Activity 2018-2030: More Active People for a Healthier World
- Exercise is Medicine Canada [website]
- Thornton JS, Frémont P, Khan K, et al. Physical Activity Prescription: A Critical Opportunity to Address a Modifiable Risk Factor for the Prevention and Management of Chronic Disease: A Position Statement by the Canadian Academy of Sport and Exercise Medicine. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine 2016;26(4):259-65. DOI: 10.1097/JSM.0000000000000363
- WHO (2010) Global recommendations on physical activity for health. WHO (2018) More active people for a healthier world.
- Booth FW, Roberts CK, Laye MJ. Lack of exercise is a major cause of chronic diseases. Comprehensive Physiology 2012;2(2):1143-211. DOI: 10.1002/cphy.c110025
- Roberts A, Wilson R, Gaul C. Incorporating exercise prescriptions into medical education. BCMJ 2021;63(6):238-41.
- Canadian Society for Exercise Physiology. Canadian 24-hour Movement Guidelines, 2021. https://csepguidelines.ca
- Petrella RJ, Lattanzio CN. Does counseling help patients get active? Systematic review of the literature. Canadian Family Physician. 2002;48:72–80.
- Foster C, Hillsdon M, Thorogood M, et al. Interventions for promoting physical activity. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2005, Issue 1. Art. No.: CD003180.
- Muller-Riemenschneider F, Reinhold T, Nocon M, Willich SN. Long-term effectiveness of interventions promoting physical activity: A systematic review. Preventive Medicine 2008;47(4): 354-68. DOI: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2008.07.006
- Pavey TG, Taylor AH, Fox KR, et al. Effect of exercise referral schemes in primary care on physical activity and improving health outcomes: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ 2011;343:d6462. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.d6462
- Orrow G, Kinmonth, A, Sanderson S, Sutton S. Effectiveness of physical activity promotion based in primary care: Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ 2012;344:e1389. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.e1389
- Stevens Z, Barlow C, Kendrick D, et al. Effectiveness of general practice-based physical activity promotion for older adults: systematic review. Primary Health Care Research & Development. 2014;15(2):190–201. DOI: 10.1017/S1463423613000017
- Codima A, das Neves Silva W, de Souza Borges AP, de Castro G Jr. Exercise prescription for symptoms and quality of life improvements in lung cancer patients: a systematic review. Supportive Care in Cancer. 2021;29(1):445-57.
- Riebe D, Franklin BA, Thompson PD, et al. Updating ACSM’s Recommendations for Exercise Preparticipation Health Screening. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 2015;47(11):2473–9. DOI: 10.1249/MSS.0000000000000664
- Powell KE, King AC, Buchner DM, et al. The Scientific Foundation for the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans, 2nd Edition. Journal of Physical Activity and Health 2018;1-11.
- Saint-Maurice PF, Graubard BI, Troiano RP, et al. Estimated Number of Deaths Prevented Through Increased Physical Activity Among US Adults. JAMA Internal Medicine 2022;182(3):349–52. DOI: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2021.7755
- Fogg BJ. A behavior model for persuasive design. DOI: 10.1145/1541948.1541999
John Sloan MDPosted at 10:43h, 15 August
I was a bit surprised by the Therapeutics Letter number 137 about physical activity. Usually your excellent reviews describe health outcomes or lack of them resulting from a therapeutic intervention. Here, the interventions are essentially telling or enabling people to exercise, but the outcome described isn’t health, but more of the intervention: exercise. I don’t prescribe much anymore being semiretired, but it would take more than evidence supporting that people told to exercise might exercise for me to “prescribe” it to anyone. I like your messages best when they deal with improving people’s health (or not) as opposed to cheerleading for popular ideas.
Thanks and keep up the good work!
Dr. John Sloan submitted a “Disclosure of interest” declaration showing that he has no conflicts of interest.